Neuropsychologist Diego Álvarez Ceballos presents a clinical guide to the differential diagnosis of acquired brain injury (ABI).
Differential diagnosis of acquired brain injury (ABI) represents a complex clinical challenge due to the considerable heterogeneity of these neurological injuries. In this guide, we examine the key elements of a comprehensive neuropsychological assessment for accurately distinguishing neurodegenerative disorders from the main ABI profiles, such as stroke, traumatic brain injury (TBI), and brain tumors. We also review the most common diagnostic errors in clinical practice and highlight the importance of a holistic approach to guide early neurorehabilitation that significantly improves patients’ quality of life.
What is acquired brain injury (ABI)? Definition and prevalence
The term acquired brain injury, or “ABI,” is widely used, but it is difficult to define, largely because of the considerable heterogeneity involved. However, ABI can be understood as “an injury of any origin that occurs acutely in the brain, causing permanent neurological impairment that limits the individual’s previous functional capacity and quality of life” (Castellanos-Pinedo et al., 2012).
An estimated 414,680 people in Spain live with an ABI (FEDACE, 2026), accounting for approximately 10% of all causes of disability in the country (INE, 2026). Although ABI can have many different causes, the two most common are stroke (the leading cause, accounting for ~80% of cases) and traumatic brain injury (TBI; ~10%). Other, less prevalent causes (<10%) include hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy (anoxia), tumors or neoplasms, CNS infections (viral, bacterial, prion-related…), autoimmune neuroinflammatory conditions, or encephalopathies of exogenous origin (substance use, exposure to indirect harmful factors…), among others.
Levels of diagnosis in differential neuropsychological assessment
In clinical practice, it can sometimes be difficult to determine and/or define the boundaries of ABI, as well as its impact on the person’s life. At this point, the role of neuropsychological assessment becomes especially important. It is a fundamental part of the final diagnosis, which results from the work of a specialized multidisciplinary team (e.g., medicine, speech-language pathology, occupational therapy, physical therapy, radiology technicians, etc.).
What do we mean by neuropsychological assessment? Junqué and Barroso (2004) define neuropsychological assessment as “a comprehensive evaluation of cognitive, behavioral, and emotional functions that may be affected as a result of functional and/or structural impairment of the central nervous system” (González Rodríguez, 2012).
Although its nature may vary depending on the reason for the assessment or its ultimate purpose, one of its goals is to provide information to make or suggest a differential diagnosis between apparently similar conditions. Some authors note that, from a neuropsychological perspective, there are four main types of neuropsychological diagnosis (Ardila and Ostrosky, 2012):
- Symptom-based diagnosis: Describes the impairments or symptoms reported by the patient (descriptive; e.g., “Frequently forgets words”).
- Etiological diagnosis: Identifies the cause or origin of the disorder or impairment (causal; e.g., TBI, stroke, Alzheimer’s disease…).
- Topographic diagnosis: Determines the anatomical location of the brain lesion or dysfunction (localization-based; e.g., left frontal lesion, medial temporal involvement…).
- Syndromic diagnosis: Identifies the neuropsychological syndrome present. According to Ardila and Ostrosky, this is the ultimate goal of neuropsychological assessment (integrative; e.g., aphasia, amnesia, apraxia, agnosia, dysexecutive syndrome…).
While some diagnoses in neuropsychology tend to be more deterministic (e.g., syndromic or symptom-based diagnoses), others are largely probabilistic (e.g., etiological diagnosis: “possible” or “consistent with” Alzheimer’s disease), requiring greater interdisciplinary collaboration to reach a definitive conclusion.
Differential diagnosis: ABI versus neurodegenerative disorders
Neuropsychological assessment should be understood as a complex, integrative, and dynamic process that goes beyond simply administering psychometric tests (reductionism).
“In a very real sense there is virtually no such thing as a neuropsychological test. Only the method of drawing inferences about the tests is neuropsychological.” (Kevin Walsh, 1992).
To this end, the trained professional (psychologist) gathers biographical, contextual, and functional information about the affected person (directly or through their immediate social network) using three main methods: the initial interview, behavioral observation, and administration of standardized tests. The information gathered is integrated and analyzed to arrive at a clinical judgment (Tirapu-Ustárroz, 2007; Martínez-Nogueras and Tirapu-Ustárroz, 2016).
However, because of the wide variability and dynamic nature of both the injury (nature or mechanism, location, extent, boundaries, time course…) and the individual (age, development, educational level, cognitive reserve, comorbidities, social environment…), it can sometimes be difficult to distinguish between similar neurological profiles, and clinically significant errors may occur. Knowledge of semiology (the study of features characteristic of a pathology) and a holistic, candid, and integrative perspective can be the first keys to the diagnostic process.
Given the breadth of the topic, the following is a schematic overview of some key considerations for diagnosing ABI in comparison with neurodegenerative disorder profiles, as well as common presentations of ABI (stroke, traumatic brain injury (TBI), and space-occupying lesions or tumors).
| Acquired brain injury (ABI) | Neurodegenerative disorders | |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Onset | Sudden and abrupt (minutes or hours). | Progressive, developing over time (months or years). |
| Key point: During the initial interview, the timing of the first detected symptoms tends to be clearer in ABI profiles, compared with the more diffuse time course of neurodegenerative disorders. | ||
| 2. Independence and functioning | Sudden loss of independence, followed by gradual recovery (varies by profile). | Progressive loss of functioning and increasing dependence. |
| Key point: During the initial interview, family members of people with ABI often report a gradual recovery of functioning after the injury, in contrast to the opposite pattern in neurodegenerative disorders, where they typically describe a progressive loss of functioning and cessation of daily activities the person used to perform. | ||
| 3. Neurocognitive profile | Greater stability. Profiles are more clearly defined over time. They tend to remain stable or improve over time (beyond expected fluctuations). | Greater variability, including within psychometric assessment. Typically, there is decline over time. |
| Key point: In neuropsychological assessment, triangulating cognitive processes (administering several tests that assess the same process) tends to show greater stability and consistency in ABI profiles than in neurodegenerative disorders, which show greater fluctuations. Medium- or long-term comparisons tend to show improvement or stability in ABI profiles, compared with decline in neurodegenerative disorders (test-retest). | ||
| 4. Behavioral and emotional profile | Greater initial severity, followed by gradual reduction. | Gradual onset. In the early stages, changes may be mistaken for normal behavior or explained by contextual factors. |
| Key point: In ABI, behaviors tend to be more limiting or dysfunctional in the early stages, unlike the typical pattern in neurodegenerative disorders. They are often mistaken for emotional problems (despite the absence of a clear contextual cause). In addition, awareness tends to increase in ABI and decline progressively in neurodegenerative disorders (it may be useful to administer questionnaires to both the family and the patient to assess level of insight). | ||
| 5. Performance and fatigue | Cumulative fatigue; cognitive functions fail or cease during task performance. The person may be unable to complete tasks during assessment in therapy, despite completing them at home through contextual automaticity. | Similar performance fluctuations during assessment and at home, but they are less abrupt (functions do not fail) and more global. |
| Key point: Observe performance during testing: does the person start appropriately but worsen as the task progresses, make more errors, or even stop the activity (more common in ABI), or do they instead show difficulty getting started or more pervasive difficulties? | ||
| 6. Adaptation and compensation | Greater difficulty adapting in the early stages (more abrupt impairment). Gradual acquisition of compensatory strategies. | Better adaptation to the natural environment in the early stages (progressive impairment). Natural compensatory strategies are used, then progressively abandoned or become less effective over time. |
| Key point: Family members often report greater difficulty adapting to everyday contexts in ABI (emotional distress), but better behavioral adjustment (following rules or guidelines). In contrast, neurodegenerative disorders typically involve the gradual emergence of maladaptive behaviors, despite appropriate adjustment to the familiar environment. | ||
Common differential diagnosis: Stroke, traumatic brain injury, and tumors
| Stroke | Traumatic brain injury (TBI) | Tumors or space-occupying lesions | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Onset and time course | Sudden and abrupt (minutes, hours, or days), associated with a specific focal event. Initial decline followed by continued positive progression. | Sudden and abrupt (associated with the time of impact). Subsequent course is variable and fluctuates over time. | Progressive and insidious (months or years). Gradual decline that develops rapidly or slowly (depending on type). |
| Key point: During the initial interview, the onset or origin of decline is usually clearly defined in time in stroke or TBI, whereas it tends to be more diffuse with space-occupying lesions. Similarly, stroke recovery is typically described in positive terms, while the course of TBI is more variable and space-occupying lesions are generally associated with progressive functional decline. | |||
| 2. Neuroanatomical pattern and topography | Localized, well-defined lesion. Corresponds to a classic neuroanatomical neurocognitive syndrome (localization-based). | Diffuse-focal profile. Focal impact injury combined with diffuse axonal injury (DAI). | Combination of focal and diffuse effects due to direct disruption of connectivity and large-scale neural networks from mass effect/compression. |
| Key point: In the interview and on psychometric tests, stroke is reflected in specific, circumscribed deficits corresponding to a particular vascular territory, whereas TBI and space-occupying lesions involve features that reveal pervasive dysfunction associated with broader networks or areas, with more impaired overall performance (well-defined versus diffuse impairment). | |||
| 3. Neurocognitive and systemic profile | Specific and well-defined profile with clear dissociations (“all or nothing”): some functions are severely affected while others are fully preserved. | Systemic impairment of basic processes (processing speed, attention, executive functions), with secondary effects on other processes (e.g., memory impairment due to slowed processing speed). | Diffuse cognitive impairment (fatigue, processing speed, attention, memory) and a less pure profile, influenced by medications or surgery. |
| Key point: In psychometric assessment, stroke presents with clear dissociations between specific tests (“all or nothing”), whereas TBI typically involves primary systemic impairment with secondary effects on other processes (e.g., attentional difficulties or slowed processing speed may secondarily lead to memory or language errors). In space-occupying lesions and TBI, clinical observation reveals marked fluctuations, particularly in attention, as well as early cognitive fatigue that family members notice clearly in everyday routines. | |||
| 4. Personality, behavior, and emotional state | Reactive or focal neurological features, largely dependent on lesion location. | High prevalence of personality and behavioral changes (e.g., apathy, disinhibition) due to frontal involvement. | Subtle or progressive personality changes and/or features consistent with emotional symptoms (e.g., pseudodepressive presentations or reactive anxiety). |
| Key point: During the initial interview and in family questionnaires, TBI is associated with reported drastic personality changes and maladaptive behaviors (e.g., disinhibition or severe apathy). In contrast, observation and history-taking in space-occupying lesions may reveal a gradual decline in performance or contextual emotional withdrawal (with no apparent cause for the symptoms), while emotional changes in stroke are usually a reaction to the sudden functional loss reported by the patient. | |||
| 5. Awareness of deficits and metacognition | Awareness of deficits is usually preserved (except in specific cases of anosognosia following right hemisphere/parietal stroke). | High frequency of impaired awareness of deficits (anosognosia) and their impact on daily functioning. | Progressive metacognitive impairment, usually masked by adaptation processes or contextual attributions. |
| Key point: During clinical observation and by comparing functional questionnaires (patient versus family), TBI is associated with marked anosognosia and overestimation of abilities. In space-occupying lesions, failures may be progressively masked or rationalized, while in stroke, awareness of deficits is usually adequate and there is an explicit request for help from the beginning of the assessment. | |||
| 6. Adaptation, compensation, and performance | Gradual adaptation associated with targeted rehabilitation of the affected function, with more predictable and estimable recovery or plateaus. Performance typically improves, and compensatory strategies are beneficial. | Performance and adaptation to the environment fluctuate. Semiological features may emerge under overload (e.g., dysexecutive features). | Gradual adaptive profile. Compensation is common as the lesion progressively grows until it exceeds a critical threshold. |
| Key point: During observation of complex tasks and test-retest assessment, TBI may involve a breakdown in performance or signs of cognitive overload in response to environmental demands. In space-occupying lesion profiles, natural compensatory strategies are initially used but progressively fail (as reported by people in the individual’s everyday environment), in contrast to the plateau or more predictable progression reported in cases of stroke. | |||
Common errors in the differential diagnosis of brain injury
The following is a list of common errors in differential neuropsychological assessment:
- Psychometric reductionism: Interpreting results by prioritizing or using only psychometric test scores, rather than holistically integrating all the information gathered.
- Confusing statistical normality with clinical normality: Interpreting average scores as “absence of impairment” without adjusting for the individual’s premorbid level or cognitive reserve.
- Prototype bias and etiological inference: Reaching a premature conclusion and/or ruling out a neuropsychological profile because it does (or does not) match the “typical or classic profile” for a given etiology (reflecting a lack of knowledge about atypical profiles), or conversely, inferring etiology (without other techniques to validate the hypothesis) because the neuropsychological profile is prototypical.
- Confusing primary and secondary difficulties: Focusing superficially on an error and directly attributing it to the corresponding process without investigating the underlying mechanism through qualitative analysis and hypothesis testing (the relationship between cognitive processes).
- Equating clinical performance with real-world functioning: Assuming that performance in the clinic is equivalent to performance in the natural environment (and vice versa), while ignoring compensatory strategies and automatic behaviors.
- Localization error (neural determinism): Unambiguously associating a specific cognitive error with a particular brain region, while overlooking the brain’s network-based functioning (connectome and diaschisis).
- Validating subjective complaints through objective cognitive deficits: Failure to detect subjective complaints (symptoms) on standardized tests neither rules out nor confirms their validity.

Subscribe
to our
Newsletter
Practical recommendations for holistic neuropsychological assessment
The following are a series of practical recommendations for increasing the efficiency of the assessment process and avoiding the errors described above:
- Take your time during the initial interview and make sure you gather all the information you need. Establish a good estimate of the patient’s premorbid level by creating a timeline and detailed map of symptoms (when and where the reported difficulties began and occur). Whenever possible, do not rely on a single information source; seek to corroborate the data gathered in context.
- Actively observe behavior throughout the assessment. Pay attention to and record how and when errors occur. It may be especially useful to note their frequency (occasional or recurrent), stability (consistent or fluctuating), or reactivity (responses to specific stimuli, due to interference, or unrelated), as well as the compensatory strategies used and the person’s awareness of deficits.
- Select a battery of standardized tests suited to the patient’s needs (sociocultural background, language, age…) and that gathers the necessary information. It is especially important to feel confident administering the tests, so complete training beforehand if appropriate. Conduct an appropriate general screening and investigate the difficulties observed and reported during the interview in greater depth, triangulating the results to reduce potential test-related artifacts. Whenever possible, make the assessment ecologically valid (gather contextual information) and efficient (do not administer more tests than necessary).
- Take a critical, integrative, and broad perspective when making a clinical judgment. Describe your observations in detail in a clear, concise, and understandable report. Formulate and test hypotheses by bringing together all the information gathered, and refer to the relevant scientific literature (especially on cognitive semiology). When making the final diagnostic conclusion, be aware of the limitations and seek input from other professionals (interdisciplinary collaboration is one of the key elements).
Implications of clinical judgment for multidisciplinary neurorehabilitation
Today, neuropsychological assessment has become a key tool in the differential diagnosis of ABI, providing crucial functional, biographical, and contextual information that is sometimes overlooked by other techniques (e.g., biomarker testing or neuroimaging). As a result, neuropsychological findings complement the detection of possible neurological conditions (multidisciplinary work) and can sometimes anticipate findings in seizure-related or mild cases (early detection).
Assessment also enables subsequent individualized, tailored intervention for the cognitive, behavioral, and emotional deficits identified, reducing their impact on daily functioning and related distress for both the patient and those around them. Despite its complexity, conducting an appropriate differential assessment can be key to ensuring other people’s quality of life, and should therefore be carried out with commitment, rigor, a broad perspective, and collaboration.
References
- Ardila, A., and Ostrosky-Solís, F. (2012). Guide to Neuropsychological Diagnosis. Manual Moderno.
- Balasa, M., Gelpi, E., Antonell, A., Sánchez-Valle, R., Lladó, A., and Molinuevo, J. L. (2011). Clinical features and neuropathological findings in early-onset dementia: A 13-year cohort study in a tertiary referral center. Journal of Alzheimer’s Disease, 26(3), 517–526. https://doi.org/10.3233/JAD-2011- 110291
- Bigler, E. D. (2013). Traumatic brain injury, neuroimaging, and neurodegeneration. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 7, Article 395. https://doi.org/10.3389/fnhum.2013.00395
- Castellanos-Pinedo, F., Cid-Gala, M., Duque, P., Ramírez-Moreno, J. M., and Zurdo Hernández, J. M. (2012). Acquired brain injury: Proposed definition, diagnostic criteria, and classification. Revista de Neurología, 54(6), 357–366. https://doi.org/10.33588/rn.5406.2011714
- Chaudhuri, A. and Behan, P. O. (2004). Fatigue in neurological disorders. The Lancet, 363(9413), 978-988. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(04)15794-2
- Spanish Federation of Acquired Brain Injury (FEDACE). (2026). Acquired brain injury is a major but little-known disability. https://fedace.org/dano-cerebral
- Garre-Olmo, J., López-Pousa, S., Vilalta-Franch, J., de Gracia Blanco, M., and Franch-Nadal, J. (2016). Etiology and prevalence of cognitive impairment in the Spanish population: The REGICOR Study. Revista Española de Geriatría y Gerontología, 45(2), 78–84. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.regg.2009.10.008
- González Rodríguez, B. (Coord.). (2012). Acquired Brain Injury: Assessment, Diagnosis, and Rehabilitation. Síntesis.
- Heaton, R. K., Temkin, N. R., Dikmen, S., Avitable, N., Taylor, M. J., Marcotte, T. D. and Grant, I. (2001). Stability and course of neuropsychological deficits in clinical populations. Journal of the International Neuropsychological Society, 7(6), 620-631. https://doi.org/10.1017/s1355617701766020
- National Statistics Institute (INE). (2026). Survey on Disability, Personal Autonomy, and Dependency Situations (EDAD). INE base. https://www.ine.es/dyngs/INEbase/es/operacion.htm?c=Estadistica_C&cid=12 54736176782&idp=1254735573175
- Iverson, G. L. (2001). Interpreting change in neuropsychological assessment: Basic concepts. NeuroRehabilitation, 16(4), 255-263. https://doi.org/10.3233/NRE-2001-16408
- Karr, J. E., Graham, R. B., Hofer, S. M. and Garcia-Barrera, M. A. (2018). The longitudinal trajectory of everyday functioning in neurodegenerative disorders. Neuropsychology, 32(4), 412-425. https://doi.org/10.1037/neu0000429
- Lezak, M. D., Howieson, D. B., Bigler, E. D. and Tranel, D. (2012). Neuropsychological Assessment (5th ed.). Oxford University Press.
- Martínez-Nogueras, A., & Tirapu-Ustárroz, J. (2016). Neuropsychological assessment: A review. Cuadernos de Medicina Psicosomática y Psiquiatría del Enlace, (118), 45–56. https://scielo.isciii.es/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S1132-05592007000200005
- Prigatano, G. P. (2005). Disturbances of self-awareness after brain injury. Clinical Neuropsychology and Cost Outcome Research (pp. 63-78). Psychology Press.
- Tirapu Ustárroz, J. (2007). Neuropsychological assessment. Intervención Psicosocial, 16(2), 189-211. https://scielo.isciii.es/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S1132-05592007000200005
- Walsh, K. (1992). Some gnomes worth knowing. The Clinical Neuropsychologist, 6(2), 119–133. https://doi.org/10.1080/13854049208401849
- Wilson, B. A. (2009). Neuropsychological Rehabilitation: Theory, Therapy, and Outcome. Cambridge University Press.
Frequently asked questions about differential diagnosis in ABI
1. What is acquired brain injury (ABI), and what are its most common causes?
ABI is an acute brain injury that causes permanent neurological impairment, limiting a person’s independence and prior functional abilities. The main causes are stroke, which accounts for around 80% of cases, and traumatic brain injury (TBI), which accounts for approximately 10%. ABI can also result from tumors, anoxia, or infections of the central nervous system.
2. How can ABI be distinguished from a neurodegenerative disorder in the clinical setting?
The main key to neuropsychological differential diagnosis is the time course. ABI is characterized by sudden onset and an abrupt loss of functioning, usually followed by stabilization or gradual recovery of skills. In contrast, neurodegenerative disorders have a prolonged, diffuse onset over time, associated with gradual cognitive and functional decline.
3. What cognitive differences are there between stroke and traumatic brain injury (TBI)?
In neuropsychological assessment, stroke is associated with highly specific and circumscribed deficits due to a localized lesion, with clear dissociations in which some functions are severely affected while others are fully preserved. In contrast, TBI typically presents with a more diffuse profile involving broader networks. This results in pervasive impairments (such as attention problems or secondary memory difficulties) and greater impairment in awareness of deficits (anosognosia).
4. What are the most common errors in the differential diagnosis of brain injury?
Common errors include psychometric reductionism, which occurs when tests are interpreted in isolation without holistically integrating the patient’s biographical and contextual information. Other frequent errors include confusing statistical normality with clinical normality (ignoring premorbid level), equating performance in the clinic with actual performance at home, and inferring etiology based solely on a prototypical profile.







Occupational Therapy in a Breast Cancer Unit
Leave a Reply